About Brotherhood Mutual
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company® exists to serve America's churches and related ministries by providing customizable insurance products, outstanding claims service, and quality safety services.
Our Story. Protecting churches and ministries has been our passion for more than 90 years. Today, Brotherhood Mutual is one of the nation's top three insurers of churches and related ministries.
Our Mission. Advancing the Kingdom by serving the Church, we will uphold the Biblical values upon which the company was founded. This is represented by our corporate verse, Galatians 6:2-"Bear ye one another's burdens and so fulfill the law of Christ."
Our Financial Hallmark. With more than $336 million in admitted assets, we consistently earn an A (Excellent) rating from A.M. Best, a leading authority in rating insurance companies, and we're reinsured by more than a dozen A and A+ rated reinsurers with billions in admitted assets. We've also been ranked among the Ward Top 50 Insurers for two years running.
Our Agents. As independent professionals, our agents understand the insurance needs of ministry customers. They have experience and training with insuring ministries, subscribe to a code of ethics based on scriptural principles, and serve in churches and ministries of their own. Your Brotherhood Mutual agent can help you assess your ministry's risks, explain insurance products, recommend coverage, and provide the service you deserve.
What they offer
Superior Insurance Products. Our insurance products are designed specifically to meet the unique needs of ministries. They can be tailored to fit any ministry, large or small. We offer insurance for property and liability, commercial auto, workers' compensation, and foreign travel.
Outstanding Claim Service. More than 98 percent of our customers say we handle their insurance claims fairly, promptly, and courteously.
Quality Safety Services. Because of our passion to help ministries succeed, we provide unparalleled safety resources and services designed specifically for ministries. As a customer, you'll have access to free legal assistance, safety guidebooks, checklists, how-to articles, and more. You'll also be eligible to receive discounts on safety services, including background screening, security training, and online safety training.